Chronic Pain Forums of the Pain Relief Network (PRN)

Opinions and expressions of the members of this forum are not the responsibility of PRN.

You are not logged in.

Announcement

NOTICE! THIS FORUM IS NOW CLOSED TO NEW MEMBERSHIPS. PLEASE BEAR WITH US AS WE MIGRATE OVER TO THE NEW FORUM. WE WILL ANNOUNCE MORE INFO AS IT BECOMES AVAILABLE. PLEASE HANG WITH US, WE LOVE YOU ALL.
New Forum address: http://painreliefnetwork.org/forums/
Register Here: http://painreliefnetwork.org/wp-signup.php
Thanks, axe
Topic rating: 0

#1 2008-04-06 09:40:34

docalex
Chief Admin
Administrator
docalex's Avatar
United_States
Gender: male
From: New York City
Registered: 2008-01-09
Posts: 986
Group: Administrators
Karma: 188
Website

Prescription Drug Propaganda

Prescription Drug Propaganda - Conflating Opioid Therapy with Addiction; Alex DeLuca; War on Doctors/Pain Crisis blog of the Pain Relief Network; 2007-08-15. Revised: 2008-04–05.

See also:
Red Flags! - the Continuing Medical Education (CME) Course!




Every once in a while it is important to fully immerse oneself in the madness, to read every sentence of a simplistic, boring, rewrite of a hateful passion play a century old, almost entirely lies. It is dirty, time-consuming work, but it is also grounding as in, ‘this is the Big Lie - if not specifically challenged it gains in strength.’

So let’s get to work. Our subject of analysis today is, ‘Here to Help’ - Heroin Addicts Grateful for Local Clinic by S.E. Lindt of the Lancaster PA Intelligencer Journal, 2007-08-14. This story can be seen as, and presents itself as, a personal tale of getting help, substitution therapy, decent clinics, good docs, of being a patient instead of a criminal. And all of these are personal, medical, or societal goods, no argument; and all are touched upon in one way or another in the article.

What is wrong with the article is that the bulk of it is classic ‘purple prose’ about the thrills and thrall of opioid use and withdrawal - soft junkie porn for the masses. It is propaganda demonizing opioid analgesics as inherently ‘addicting’, which under the Controlled Substances Act means, literally, ‘criminalizing.’ This is necessary to gain passive public acceptance of the federal targeting of pain doctors as drug dealers, and of pain patients as addicts temporarily protected from their just deserts by said venal docs.

http://doctordeluca.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/recreationaldrugvsadrdeath02.jpg
The chart 1 is included for perspective - “PharmCo” refers to adverse drug reactions to all prescribed meds, for example, hospital med dispensing errors. Illegal drug use includes “non-medical” prescription drug use. Note cannabis deaths = zero.

This paragraph has pretty much all of the elements that bug me about the article:

“Hartley soon found himself “doctor shopping” and visiting local ERs to maintain a 60-pill-a-day addiction to this popular opioid. The little pills pack a whopping high when misused — that is, crushed and snorted or injected into a vein. A lesser-known fact about this and other opioids is that they hook users for life by changing their brain chemistry.”

“The little pills pack a whopping high… crushed and snorted or injected…” - there’s your soft porn, along with all those tales of tears for missed kids birthdays, and having a hard time hitching a ride to the clinic (oh the humanity!) that pepper this article.

But it is the last sentence, above, and the spirit of that sentence relentlessly pounded home, that is very damaging for pain patients.

“A lesser-known fact about this and other opioids is that they hook users for life by changing their brain chemistry.”



Outrageous. Pure dis-information. Opioid therapy, titrated to analgesic effect, is empowering to pain patients - when successful, they pick up their beds and walk, that is, they have a life, and it is a beautiful thing to see.

Your government wants very much that you believe that opioids magically criminalize people, that daily use of opioid medications is enslaving and harmful. All lies. Without pain patients as fodder, the war on drugs falters, federal law enforcement and the substance abuse treatment industry start missing meals and getting nervous - there just aren’t enough illicit drug users to maintain the bloat.

This article under consideration could be disregarded as simply stupid and hateful to drug users or “addicts”, which would be par and hardly notable, except they start this whole soap opera off with a story of legitimate pain! Here is how the article begins:

“[A]fter a 5,000-pound machine fell on his back in a workplace accident, street heroin became [Shannon Hartley’s] eventual drug of choice. Of course, it didn’t start that way… After his injury, he was prescribed OxyContin for pain. Hartley said his physician was liberal with refills and knowingly fed his growing addiction…”

So what is the message? Well one clear message to me is that the line between pain patient and “addict” - that pitiable dregs of humanity; the walking dead; that criminal scourge; is thin and vague. In fact it is presented as the slippery slope if not an inevitability - people on chronic opioid therapy are, or will become, addicts. Pain patient, drug addict, who cares? Drug are bad, people who use them are bad, you and I are better than that; they deserve what they get.

And who are they? What is an ‘addict’? Near the middle of the article, after stating that methadone maintenance “changed Hartley’s life [for the better],” the author informs us, in authoritative tones:

But the thing about methadone is, an addict still needs a dose every single day. Without methadone, he will still go through physical and mental withdrawal - or go back to a street dealer to get an illegal high.

And there it is: “addicts” are people who take opioids daily; period. This grossly misleading disinformation is not ok for pain patients, and not ok for drug users, and may describe our baser selves, but is otherwise to be taken as federal government propaganda, IMO.

See - it’s all about the drugs, not the people. It is the drug that did all this to the man in this article, Mr. Hartely. This tale is always told in the passive sense. And that is not what drug use is like or about in the vast majority of cases, as we all know either from medical treatment, or other drug use, or drinking or knowing someone well who did some or all of these. People use drugs purposefully - for a reason. It is a decision.

In any event, pain is by far the larger societal problem, by any standard. Ass backwards like a lot of drug war phenomena - they get it exactly wrong. So exactly wrong it just feels on purpose.

And it is not just that paragraph - it is the thrust of the piece. The enlightened harm reduction’esque info and a smattering of correct sentences from doctors come only in the closing paragraphs of a very long article. And they do not alter the essentially propagandistic nature of journalism like this.

Footnote:

1.  Scherlen and Robinson; 2003; bbsnews.net ↩

[END]


..alex...
Alex DeLuca, M.D., MPH
Senior Consultant, PRN

doctordeluca@painreliefnetwork.org

 

 
 
 

#2 2008-04-06 23:18:09

tabt
Member
United_States
Gender: female
Registered: 2008-02-11
Posts: 245
Group: Members
Karma: 31
Note: "Just Blame Me"

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

Yes, Doc Alex, Tami, Ian, Kim, Frank, Lori, Deanna, Axe, Hope, and everyone else here,

Constantly reading through the endless stream of anti-opiod propaganda that relentlessly comes at us from all directions is a dirty task indeed.  Thank you all so much for doing it, because we cannot counterattack what we do not know exists.  To be honest, I have reached a point where I have to limit the amount of my reading, so that I can continue to function without being totally disheartened. I guiltily thank all of you here on this forum who do my "dirty work" for me when I just can't read or think about the war on pain patients for one more second without a break.

I am sooooo sick of hearing the "opiods change the brain forever" lie and I am so tired of having to refute it.  This is not the first time that I've seen this or the rest of the misinformation printed above used to satisfy a CME (Continuing Medical Education) requirement for doctors.  It's a truly disgusting way to kill two birds with one stone.  The doctors fulfill the CME requirements for licensure, (probably online, guaranteeing that they will never have to come into actual contact with a live, suffering pain patient), and then return to work with a whole new arsenal of lies to help them refuse to prescribe opiods and a bogus rationale to dump their pain patients by inappropriately referring them to addictionologists and anesthesiologists who do not actually treat opiod dependent chronic pain.  I also know that they teach this stuff to med students, interns, residents etc., thereby ensuring that the new generations of docs who emerge from such "training" are thoroughly steeped in lies, misinformation and the caveat to completely avoid treating pain patients, EVER.  They should have a "JUST SAY NO" motto emblazoned on the front of their lab coats.  It has gotten so bad that when I am looking for a doctor for anything,  if I see that they have graduated from medical school or completed a residency after 1995,  I automatically rule them out because I know that they have been brainwashed against people like me.  When other people ask my opinion about selecting a doctor,  I say try someone as old as possible without getting someone who plans to retire soon.  It's a terrible, but I believe accurate, assessment of the future of medicine.  I hope that I die before only the new doctors are left, because I know that they will give me no help or relief.

Even the "good patient" in the "story" who decided to accept the addiction model and go to a methadone clinic was rewarded with the label of "addict who needs a fix every day". If he misses a "fix" he apparently becomes a dangerous junkie and all hell breaks loose.  Yeah, right, must be true if a doctor says it.  It follows that all good people, (those who do not take opiods), are really in mortal danger from him, and from us, because we need our daily fixes too. Like that "good patient/addict", we need them to function, ergo we're all addicts who are, at best, drains on society. 

I, personally, believe that methadone is a bad medication for pain because it's long half life makes it extemely unpredictable, it has dangerous interactions with many other meds, it is often not very effective for stopping pain and it can easily kill people.   However, I do know that some people use it and are helped by it.  Those who are forced to go to methadone clinics pay hundreds of dollars for methadone that costs the clincs pennies.  Most insurance doesn't cover it, so if people lose their jobs, they are cut off from their meds.  These people are also often terribly abused by clinic staff members, forced to endure complete obliteration of any right to privacy, and are constantly threatened with termination of meds, cold turkey, for the slightest, actual or imagined, infraction of the most minor rules.  I encourage everyone to check out a site called "We Speak Methadone" and read some of those people's stories.  The last post I read stated that cameras were being installed in the bathrooms of clinics.  Even if you accept the addiction model, (and I, personally, don't believe this is the only way to deal with that issue),  how can anyone possibly call that "treatment"?  I call it dehumanizing tyranny.  If you treat people like criminals, and deprive them of their even their most bast human rights, it is likely that you will wind up with angry criminals.  By the way, the people being treated like this are can be completely legal patients with sustained histories of "compliance".  However,  individual situations beyond their control, are often not taken into account.

Doesn't that sound familiar?  Everything I see, hear and read tells me that all pain patients,  (it has already happened to so many of us),  will soon be relegated to the addiction model.  I fear that we will no longer have any other choice and that we will get no opiod treatment for pain, except possibly methadone or suboxone in inadequate doses. We might,  as an alternative,  be offered new, inadequately tested, expensive, under patent, off label, non-opiods that make us sick and do not help with pain. We might also, out of desperation and lack of any other options, be forced to further risk our health by accepting injections that can pose many problems.

Perhaps I am being overly pessimistic, but that really is the direction that I see so called "medicine" moving toward.  Addictionologists, who use the addiction model of getting chronic pain patients completely off opiods, have already renamed themselves "pain management" doctors in many places.  Anesthesiologists,  who also are NOT TRAINED to manage chronic pain and DO NOT USE oral opiods for treating pain, have also renamed themselves "pain management" doctors too.  Their way of "managing" chronic pain is to give injections that are of limited dosage and duration, and often, are of  limited efficacy.  (Anyone who is considering getting injections from an anesthesiologist would be wise to look up arachnoiditis, iatrogenic Cushings Syndrome, the side effects of cortisone and all the other potential risks associated with injections before they make a decision.)  These two types of doctors are now those who most chronic pain patients get dumped on, aka "referred to for pain management" that doesn't really exist.

I think THE LIE THAT I HATE MOST is the lie that primary care doctors, rheumatologists, neurologists, orthopedists, et. al. tell patients  when they say that they "cannot prescribe long term opiods" and that patients "must be referred to pain management" doctors for long term opiod prescriptions.  THEY ARE LIARS!  If you have a DEA number, and they all do, any M.D. or D.O. can prescribe any controlled substance, unless they are using methadone or suboxone TO TREAT ADDICTION, which requires a special license.  If either of those drugs are being used to treat pain, however, no special license is required.  Even your psychiatrist has a DEA number and could help you out by prescribing opiods if he or she wanted to do so.  DOCTORS CAN PRESCRIBE OPIATES, THEY'RE JUST AFRAID TO DO IT.  It may be something that they don't want to do, it may be something the senior members of their practices tell them not to do, it may be some "association's" trumped up "guideline", it may be the preference of an influential insurance company, but it is NOT THE LAW, (not yet anyway),  AND THEY CAN DO IT.
If doctors would at least be honest about their refusal to prescribe controlled substances, I might be able to summon up a modicum of compassion or respect for them, but when they tell the BIG LIE, they become nothing more than barriers to treatment.  I cannot see liars as caregivers, let alone allies.

Once all the doctors have officially reached the same, lie based consensus, whether out of fear or ignorance, where will we go?  I just don't know how to fight those lies, when doctors, the people who hold the power of the prescription pad and stand, directly,  between me and my treatment as a chronic pain patient who requires opiates, choose to embrace these lies and base their practice of "medicine" upon them.  I understand that the long term goal of PRN is the repeal of the CSA and the removal of the DEA from medicine.  I fully support and am committed to this.  However, this will take a long time to do via  the courts, the Congress, a new Attorney General to reign in the DOJ/DEA terrorist tactics, whatever is effective.  What do we do in the meantime? 

I do not believe that pain patients can fight the lies about opiods alone. Doctors must step up and help us if we are to be successful.  There are ways that they can do this and still protect themselves.  One way would be to distribute risk in a given area.  If everybody agreed to take a few opiate dependent chronic pain patients as part of the rest of their practice, they could not be easily labelled as "pill mills". Once you marginalize pain patients and force them all to go to "pain clinics", the pain clinics become very easy targets for the DEA.  Lots of prescriptions from one doctor result in a high pill count that triggers DEA investigation and federal prosecution.  I'm sure that other strategies that would protect both doctors and patients could also be developed. However, doctors, in large numbers, need to start helping us, and stop rejecting us.  Maybe I'm wrong, but I just don't see any other way out.  Am I recognizing the elephant in the living room by calling most doctors unethical liars when it comes to long term opiods for chronic pain patients?

Good doctors, you know who you are and you know that I am not talking about you.  If I have offended you with my somewhat harsh words, I am sorry.  I have said what I, as an opiod dependent chronic pain patient, felt needed to be said. I hope that you understand that I am simply doing my best to try to help solve a terrible human rights problem that no one outside of PRN wants to touch.

tabt


Evil flourishes when good people do nothing.

 

 
 
 

#3 2008-04-07 03:53:19

monkeyboy
Member
United_States
Gender: female
From: my unhappy place
Registered: 2008-01-14
Posts: 592
Group: Members
Karma: 34
Note: Spits Truth to Power

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

well done tabt--- i would go so far as to say the elephant condones torture and is little more than a state sponsored terrorist---but i'm more than a little bitter...


now if theres a smile upon my face/its only there tryin to fool the public

 

 
 
 

#4 2008-04-07 15:59:46

Tami
Smokin' Admin
Administrator
Tami's Avatar
United_States
Gender: female
Registered: 2008-01-09
Posts: 7145
Group: Administrators
Karma: 279
Note: Carpe Libertatem
Website

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

tabt wrote:

What do we do in the meantime?

Nicely written post tabt. What do we do? For me, the answer is easy enough, we support the noble work of PRN. In whatever way we can, educating, advocating, empowering the pain community. As I sit in pain everyday at my computer, it seems to motivate me. And to be a small part of this civil rights movement at this time in my life, is an honor.

But it is hugely frustrating and discouraging at times, I understand your feelings tabt.

Tami


Tami Strand Political Activist for the Pain Relief Network a Nonprofit NonPartisan 501(C)(3) Corporation. "Delaying aggressive opioid therapy in favor of trying everything else first is not rational based on a modern, scientific understanding of the pathophysiology of chronic pain, and is therefore not the standard of care." Dr. Alexander Deluca   
Rage Against The Machine

 

 
 
 

#5 2008-04-07 16:12:32

docalex
Chief Admin
Administrator
docalex's Avatar
United_States
Gender: male
From: New York City
Registered: 2008-01-09
Posts: 986
Group: Administrators
Karma: 188
Website

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

banjobabe wrote:

docalex wrote:

banjobabe wrote:

Yechchhhh..it continues!!!  God it makes me mad!!!  Sheeple are sooo joyfully ignorant, at our (cpp) cost. 

Doc Alex cuts through the propaganda like a hot knife thru butter, thanks Doc!

Ahh, Siobhan wrote this Letter to the Editor. But point taken; thanks!

******************
oops U both do actually!!
I usually try to be concise w/quotes...sorry about that! 
Kindly,
Lori
(The Relentless)!

arrgh: minor point = you were right, I was wrong, this topic is me, not siobhan.


..alex...
Alex DeLuca, M.D., MPH
Senior Consultant, PRN

doctordeluca@painreliefnetwork.org

 

 
 
 

#6 2008-04-07 23:47:12

docalex
Chief Admin
Administrator
docalex's Avatar
United_States
Gender: male
From: New York City
Registered: 2008-01-09
Posts: 986
Group: Administrators
Karma: 188
Website

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

tabt wrote:

Doesn't that sound familiar?  Everything I see, hear and read tells me that all pain patients,  (it has already happened to so many of us),  will soon be relegated to the addiction model.
tabt

No, you are correct. Everything you said is how I see it; for whatever that is worth.


..alex...
Alex DeLuca, M.D., MPH
Senior Consultant, PRN

doctordeluca@painreliefnetwork.org

 

 
 
 

#7 2008-04-20 11:26:49

hope_6
Member
hope_6's Avatar
United_States
Gender: female
From: ks
Registered: 2008-02-04
Posts: 1477
Group: Members
Karma: 60

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

SOMEONE WAS WANTING INFO ON PELVIC PAIN,SORRY BAD W/NMES HERES WHAT I FOUND  HOPE HUGSChronic Pelvic Pain

Chronic pelvic pain may occur in the presence of known or suspected organic pathology, or without any evidence of an underlying physical cause. Pelvic pain is more common in women, with most common reasons being endometriosis, endometritis, pelvic inflammatory disease, pelvic adhesions, neoplasm, and myofascial pain of the pelvic floor muscles. Pelvic pain may persist even after total hysterectomy.

Central Pain

HOPE


Before you go to bed
  Give your troubles
      to God .
He's up all night, anyway.

 

 
 
 

#8 2008-04-20 11:31:20

hope_6
Member
hope_6's Avatar
United_States
Gender: female
From: ks
Registered: 2008-02-04
Posts: 1477
Group: Members
Karma: 60

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

The Current Opioid Misuse Measure (COMM™) will help clinicians identify whether a patient, currently on long-term opioid therapy, may be exhibiting aberrant behaviors associated with misuse of opioid medications. In contrast, the Screener and Opioid Assessment for Patients with Pain (SOAPP) is intended to predict which patients, being considered for long-term opioid therapy, may exhibit aberrant medications behaviors in the future. Since the COMM examines concurrent misuse, it is ideal for helping clinicians monitor patients' aberrant medication-related behaviors over the course of treatment


Download COMM   
 
PAINedu.ORG {SOAPP]





  Last Update
4/16/2008  Newsletter Tell a Colleague Rate This Site Terms of


Before you go to bed
  Give your troubles
      to God .
He's up all night, anyway.

 

 
 
 

#9 2008-04-21 00:06:14

docalex
Chief Admin
Administrator
docalex's Avatar
United_States
Gender: male
From: New York City
Registered: 2008-01-09
Posts: 986
Group: Administrators
Karma: 188
Website

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

tabt wrote:

Yes, Doc Alex, Tami, Ian, Kim, Frank, Lori, Deanna, Axe, Hope, and everyone else here,

Constantly reading through the endless stream of anti-opiod propaganda that relentlessly comes at us from all directions is a dirty task indeed.  Thank you all so much for doing it, because we cannot counterattack what we do not know exists.  To be honest, I have reached a point where I have to limit the amount of my reading, so that I can continue to function without being totally disheartened. I guiltily thank all of you here on this forum who do my "dirty work" for me when I just can't read or think about the war on pain patients for one more second without a break. ...

I do not believe that pain patients can fight the lies about opiods alone. Doctors must step up and help us if we are to be successful.  There are ways that they can do this and still protect themselves.  One way would be to distribute risk in a given area.  If everybody agreed to take a few opiate dependent chronic pain patients as part of the rest of their practice, they could not be easily labelled as "pill mills". Once you marginalize pain patients and force them all to go to "pain clinics", the pain clinics become very easy targets for the DEA.  Lots of prescriptions from one doctor result in a high pill count that triggers DEA investigation and federal prosecution.  I'm sure that other strategies that would protect both doctors and patients could also be developed. However, doctors, in large numbers, need to start helping us, and stop rejecting us.  Maybe I'm wrong, but I just don't see any other way out.  Am I recognizing the elephant in the living room by calling most doctors unethical liars when it comes to long term opiods for chronic pain patients. ...
tabt

This is a phenomenal post - one for the keeper file. Agree with EVERY WORD. tabt is a master of this material.

You. Nailed. It.


..alex...
Alex DeLuca, M.D., MPH
Senior Consultant, PRN

doctordeluca@painreliefnetwork.org

 

 
 
 

#10 2008-09-28 05:28:17

hope_6
Member
hope_6's Avatar
United_States
Gender: female
From: ks
Registered: 2008-02-04
Posts: 1477
Group: Members
Karma: 60

Re: Prescription Drug Propaganda

Tab , i dont know how i missed this, must have been when i was gone for some time.
It couldnt be sid better ,if i may so so myself. thanks for puttting your heart into this story.and doc;s right, you nailed it. hugs hope


Before you go to bed
  Give your troubles
      to God .
He's up all night, anyway.

 

 
 
 

 

Mega Pun is Powered by PunBB
© Copyright 2002–2007 Rickard Andersson


About Us | Member Sign-up | Contact Us

© 2008 Pain Relief Network All Rights Reserved

logo.gif